Top 10 best super-saloons 2022

Open gallery Close News by James Disdale 11 mins read 24 August 2022 Share

The super-saloon market remains, as ever, fairly small but fiercely competitive. The German big three still have a huge presence, although they perhaps aren’t as dominant as they’ve have been over the years, with changing emissions legislation having shaved away the meat of certain performance brands’ model ranges – and opened the door for others to move in.

In the past few years, we’ve seen the return of Alfa Romeo to the segment. The Italian marque’s Giulia Quadrifoglio is epic and has since been joined by even more hardcore GTA and GTAm models. Meanwhile, BMW’s decision to remove the standard M5 from sale in the UK has bumped it from the top spot, with the brand new, challenging-looking but brilliant-handling M3 Competition usurping it.

As ever, power and performance figures are getting more and more impressive, with some of the cars in this list now churning out in excess of 600bhp. But output alone isn’t enough to grab the top spot. Finally, sense may be returning to this segment, and cars with just-so power and proportions and performance well balanced against real-world usability are coming back to the fore.

BMW M5 Touring to return as 700bhp-plus hybrid in 2024Autocar writers on their best moments in BMW M carsHistory of the BMW M division – picture specialBMW M5 CS 2021 UK first driveUsed car hero: Revisiting the E39 BMW M5

BMW M3 Competition

We’re now onto the sixth generation of the BMW M Division’s M3. For many, it may not seem quite the attraction it used to be, with the two-door coupé body it once called its own having been pinched by the M4. Even so, few performance cars mean so much to their manufacturers as this, and few represent such a huge event when a new one comes along.

Like every ‘G80’ 3 Series, the M3 has put on just a little size and weight relative to its predecessor, but it has also changed somewhat under the skin. This is the first M3 you can have with four driven wheels and the first that has ever come with a torque-converter automatic gearbox. There’s a six-speed manual available in come markets, too, but BMW UK offers only the choice between rear-drive and all-paw configurations, both with the automatic ‘box. Meanwhile, a new twin-turbocharged 3.0-litre straight six comes in under the bonnet, codenamed ‘S58B30T0’, making just over 500bhp and quite a bit more torque than the old ’S55’ 3.0-litre unit managed.

While the styling of this car is certain to divide opinion, the M3 Competition’s drive is easily good enough to work as a balm for your reservations. Superbly taut, poised and precise handling, allied to a superbly balanced chassis and one of the best steering racks you will find in any saloon in the world, truly set this car apart. As usual in an M3, the engine is cast in a slightly supporting role, but it has great response, linearity and clout when you call for it. The four-wheel drive system in the M3 xDrive is also one of the best around, magically guessing when you want it to feel rear-driven and when you just want ultimate traction.

The new M3 is the super-saloon class’s new benchmark. For its distinguishing blend of driver engagement, outright pace, everyday usability and performance value, nothing here is better.

Latest Drives

BMW X7 xDrive40d M Sport

Renault Clio E-Tech 2023 first drive

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio 2023 first drive

Polestar 2 Long Range Single Motor RWD 2023 first drive

Peugeot 3008 136 e-DCS6 Hybrid 2023 first drive

View all latest drives

Read our review

Car review

BMW M5

BMW’s legendary performance saloon takes the plunge into fast 4WD territory

Read our review Back to top

Save money with new 3 Series deals on What Car?

Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio

The Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio missed out on a class-leading berth here by the skin of its teeth. Excellent handling, a composed ride and gorgeous looks are order of the day – all key traits for any serious contender in this segment.

Its Ferrari-derived turbocharged V6 is also enthralling – not quite as flexible as the M3’s straight six but with its own distinct appeal. Its handling, meanwhile, is as lithe, balanced, direct and sports-car-like as it’s possible to find in anything with four doors – and very engaging with it.

Overall, this car marks a stellar return to form for a brand that had been floundering for some years. The only real shortfall – and it’s a relatively small one – is the interior, which is a bit lower-rent than those offered by Mercedes-AMG and BMW.

Save money with new Giulia deals on What Car?

3. BMW M5 CS

The addition of a CS model at the top of the M5 range has transformed BMW’s flagship bahnstormer from a very good car into one that touches greatness. Despite the badge, this isn’t some stripped-out, track-based special but car that refines and enhances the standard (and still available) M5 Competition. There’s more power (isn’t there always?), plus a raft of suspension tweaks, most of which are aimed at making the big BMW one of the most involving fast four-doors that quite a lot of cash can buy. Under the carbonfibre bonnet (one of a number of changes that helps trim 70kg from the M5’s kerb weight), the familiar 4.4-litre V8 has been massaged to deliver a thumping 626bhp. For the suspension, there are revised springs, dampers and anti-roll bars, plus a 7mm drop in ride height. Visually, the CS stands out thanks to its vast 20in forged alloy wheels, nifty yellow daytime running lights and whole host of ‘gold bronze’ trim inserts.

Get moving and its clear that BMW M’s engineers have tried to serve up a driving experience that effortlessly melds ‘super’ and ‘saloon’. Performance is bombastic, the twin-turbocharged V8 pulling with a deep-chested elasticity that opens up overtaking opportunities denied to most others. Then there’s the finely balanced handling, which offers enough agility and immediacy to have you quickly forgetting about the CS’s rather large exterior dimensions. This is truly engaging driver’s car, one that gets better the harder you drive, remaing poised and on your side when the standard Competition starts to betray its mass and size.